Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen Menu (Update 2025)
Welcome to Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen, where comfort food meets authentic Amish hospitality right in the heart of Middlefield, Ohio. Known for its mouthwatering buffet, this restaurant offers an experience reminiscent of home cooking. You'll find an array of delectable dishes featuring house-made selections, from rich, satisfying gravy to tender broasted chicken, and unforgettable homemade mashed potatoes.
Each visit promises highlights, like the Amish meatloaf and seasonal dishes, while the famous pies, especially the butterscotch and banana cream, are a must-try. The inviting atmosphere and friendly staff enhance the experience, making you feel like family with every service. Whether for a casual meal or a delightful buffet experience, Mary Yoder's is an essential stop for those craving hearty, love-filled meals in a cozy setting.
All You Can Eat Country Breakfast Buffet
Country Breakfast Buffet
Scrambled Eggs, Home Fries • Cornmeal Mush, Bacon, Sausage Gravy, Sausage, Fresh Fruit, Biscuits, Frozen Slush, Pancakes, Cheese Sauce, French Toast, Variety of Fresh Bakery Items, Real Maple Syrup available! Served Monday - Saturday & Holidays from 7 A.M. to 11 A.M.
2 Eggs, any style with toast
Served with your choice of wheat, rye, or cinnamon raisin toast. Add all you can eat pancakes to any breakfast special for an additional cost.
2 Eggs, any style
Comes with home fries, choice of bacon or sausage, choice of homemade toast, english muffin or biscuit. Served with your choice of wheat, rye, or cinnamon raisin toast. Add all you can eat pancakes to any breakfast special for an additional cost.
2 Eggs, any style, with ham
Comes with home fries, ham, choice of homemade toast, english muffin or biscuit. Served with your choice of wheat, rye, or cinnamon raisin toast. Add all you can eat pancakes to any breakfast special for an additional cost.
Breakfast Specials
3-Egg Omelettes
Mary Yoder’s Omelettes
Cheese, mushrooms, onion, ham and green peppers. Our omelettes are served with Homemade Toast, English Muffin or Biscuit. No Cholesterol, Fat Free, Egg Substitute available! Add all you can eat pancakes to any omelet for an additional cost.
Cheese Omelette
Our omelettes are served with Homemade Toast, English Muffin or Biscuit. No Cholesterol, Fat Free, Egg Substitute available! Add all you can eat pancakes to any omelet for an additional cost.
Meat & Cheese Omelette
Choose ham, bacon, or sausage. Add mushrooms or cheese sauce for an additional cost. Add home fries for an additional cost. Our omelettes are served with Homemade Toast, English Muffin or Biscuit. No Cholesterol, Fat Free, Egg Substitute available! Add all you can eat pancakes to any omelet for an additional cost.
Southwest Omelette
Chicken, peppers, onions, black beans, pepper jack cheese, topped with salsa. Our omelettes are served with Homemade Toast, English Muffin or Biscuit. No Cholesterol, Fat Free, Egg Substitute available! Add all you can eat pancakes to any omelet for an additional cost.
Geauga Breakfast Bowl
Crispy hash brown patty, 2 eggs any style, grilled peppers and onions, 2 strips of bacon, biscuit, choice of sausage gravy or cheese sauce.
Dutch Scramble
2 eggs, home fries, choice of ham, bacon, or sausage scrambled together, (mushrooms or cheese sauce add 2.49 ea.) Homemade toast, english muffin or biscuit.
Breakfast Sandwich
Egg with choice of ham, bacon, or sausage with cheese on homemade toast, english muffin or croissant.
Pancakes
3 large pancakes with bacon, ham, or sausage. Add fruit for an additional cost.
French Toast
3 pieces of your choice of our homemade cinnamon, wheat, or white breads. Add bacon, ham, or sausage for an additional cost.
Waffle & Bacon
Fresh, made-from-scratch waffle with 2 strips of bacon.
Sausage Gravy Over Biscuits
Available as a half order or whole order
Bowl of Oatmeal
Add toast or raisins for an additional cost.
Cup of Oatmeal or Grits
Add toast for an additional cost.
Farm Fresh Breakfast
A La Cart
Home Fries
Ham, Bacon, or Sausage
Sausage available as patties or links.
Homemade Toast
Choice of white, wheat, rye, or cinnamon raisin.
English Muffin
Biscuit
Bagel with Cream Cheese
Cinnamon Roll
Mini Muffins (3)
Frozen Fruit Slush
Cinnamon Sticks (3)
1 Egg, any style
1 Pancake
Cup of Sausage Gravy
Fried Mush
Available in 2 pieces or 4 pieces. Add sausage gravy for an additional cost.
French Toast
Available in 1 piece or 2 pieces.
Cup of Fruit
Fresh Fruit Parfait
Fresh fruit with vanilla yogurt and homemade granola, with your choice of homemade toast.
Buffet
Enjoy all-you-can-eat home-style meats, dressing, authentic Amish mashed potatoes, noodles, macaroni and cheese, creamed corn, green beans, salad bar and more. Served Monday-Saturday from 11:30 am. - 7:30 pm.
All You Can Eat Amish Dinner Buffet
Family Style Dinner
One Meat Family Style Dinner
Enjoy Amish-style foods served around the table the old-fashioned family way! Family Style Includes: Your Choice of Meat(s), Mashed Potatoes, Dressing, Vegetable, Gravy, Homemade Rolls, Salad Bar, Beverage(s) (No shakes or floats). Meat choices are: Oven Baked Chicken, Broasted Chicken, Ham, Roast Beef, Roast Turkey, Roast Pork. This is priced per person. We ask that all guests at your table order family-style with a minimum of 5 guests. Eat all you want, but no leftovers to take home. Gratuity not included.
Two Meat Family Style Dinner
Enjoy Amish-style foods served around the table the old-fashioned family way! Family Style Includes: Your Choice of Meat(s), Mashed Potatoes, Dressing, Vegetable, Gravy, Homemade Rolls, Salad Bar, Beverage(s) (No shakes or floats). Meat choices are: Oven Baked Chicken, Broasted Chicken, Ham, Roast Beef, Roast Turkey, Roast Pork. This is priced per person. We ask that all guests at your table order family-style with a minimum of 5 guests. Eat all you want, but no leftovers to take home. Gratuity not included.
Three Meat Family Style Dinner
Enjoy Amish-style foods served around the table the old-fashioned family way! Family Style Includes: Your Choice of Meat(s), Mashed Potatoes, Dressing, Vegetable, Gravy, Homemade Rolls, Salad Bar, Beverage(s) (No shakes or floats). Meat choices are: Oven Baked Chicken, Broasted Chicken, Ham, Roast Beef, Roast Turkey, Roast Pork. This is priced per person. We ask that all guests at your table order family-style with a minimum of 5 guests. Eat all you want, but no leftovers to take home. Gratuity not included.
Hamburger
Cheeseburger
Your choice of Middlefield Swiss or American Swiss
Garden Burger
Served with lettuce and tomato
Turkey Sandwich
Homemade bread, lettuce and tomato
Breaded Cod Fish Sandwich
Ham & Swiss Sandwich
Made with Middlefield Swiss cheese
Hot Dog
Roast Beef Sandwich
Corned Beef Reuben
Middlefield Swiss and Sauerkraut on Grilled Rye bread with your choice of one side dish
Chicken Salad Sandwich
Tuna Salad Sandwich
Grilled Chicken Sandwich
Grilled chicken breast, lettuce, and tomato
BBQ Beef or Pork Sandwich
Grilled Cheese Sandwich
Your choice of Middlefield Swiss or American Cheese
BLT
Yoder’s Ground Steak Sandwich
Grilled onions and peppers with Middlefield Swiss cheese and your choice of one side dish
Hot Trail Bologna and Swiss Sandwich
Trail Bologna and melted Middlefield Swiss on homemade bread
Turkey Bacon Wrap
Your choice of side
Half Chicken Salad Sandwich with your choice of a Cup of Soup
For soups, choose from Vegetable, Chili, Chicken Noodle, or ask your server for the Soup of the Day!
Half BBQ Beef Sandwich with your choice of a Cup of Soup
For soups, choose from Vegetable, Chili, Chicken Noodle, or ask your server for the Soup of the Day!
Half Roast Beef Sandwich with your choice of a Cup of Soup
For soups, choose from Vegetable, Chili, Chicken Noodle, or ask your server for the Soup of the Day!
Sandwiches
Dinners
Slow Roasted Pork
Dinner include homemade rolls and two side dishes of your choice. Substitute one side dish for the Salad Bar for an additional cost. Available in a smaller portion as a Senior Dinner, 60.
Roast Turkey (all white meat)
Dinner include homemade rolls and two side dishes of your choice. Substitute one side dish for the Salad Bar for an additional cost. Available in a smaller portion as a Senior Dinner, 60.
Amish-Style Roast Beef
Dinner include homemade rolls and two side dishes of your choice. Substitute one side dish for the Salad Bar for an additional cost. Available in a smaller portion as a Senior Dinner, 60.
Broasted or Baked Chicken: Breast & Thigh
Dinner include homemade rolls and two side dishes of your choice. Substitute one side dish for the Salad Bar for an additional cost. Available in a smaller portion, 1 Chicken Breast, as a Senior Dinner, 60.
Broasted or Baked Chicken: Breast, Thigh and Drum
Dinner include homemade rolls and two side dishes of your choice. Substitute one side dish for the Salad Bar for an additional cost.
Broasted or Baked Chicken: Drum & Thigh
Dinner include homemade rolls and two side dishes of your choice. Substitute one side dish for the Salad Bar for an additional cost. Available in a smaller portion as a Senior Dinner, 60.
2 Breaded Pork Chops
Dinner include homemade rolls and two side dishes of your choice. Substitute one side dish for the Salad Bar for an additional cost. Available in a smaller portion, 1 breaded pork chop, as a Senior Dinner, 60.
Breaded Cod
Dinner include homemade rolls and two side dishes of your choice. Substitute one side dish for the Salad Bar for an additional cost. Available in a smaller portion as a Senior Dinner, 60.
Breaded Shrimp (7)
Dinner include homemade rolls and two side dishes of your choice. Substitute one side dish for the Salad Bar for an additional cost. Available in a smaller portion as a Senior Dinner, 60.
Crispy Chicken Tenders (4)
Dinner include homemade rolls and two side dishes of your choice. Substitute one side dish for the Salad Bar for an additional cost. Available in a smaller portion as a Senior Dinner, 60.
Pan Fried Chicken Tenders
Dinner include homemade rolls and two side dishes of your choice. Substitute one side dish for the Salad Bar for an additional cost.
Homemade Meatloaf
Dinner include homemade rolls and two side dishes of your choice. Substitute one side dish for the Salad Bar for an additional cost. Available in a smaller portion as a Senior Dinner, 60.
Grilled Chicken Breast
Dinner include homemade rolls and two side dishes of your choice. Substitute one side dish for the Salad Bar for an additional cost.
Grilled Ham with Pineapple Glaze
Dinner include homemade rolls and two side dishes of your choice. Substitute one side dish for the Salad Bar for an additional cost. Available in a smaller portion as a Senior Dinner, 60.
Breaded Walleye
Dinner include homemade rolls and two side dishes of your choice. Substitute one side dish for the Salad Bar for an additional cost.
Salmon
Dinner include homemade rolls and two side dishes of your choice. Substitute one side dish for the Salad Bar for an additional cost.
Manhattan
Hot sandwich served with your choice of Roast Beef, Roast Pork, Roast Turkey or Meatloaf, mashed potatoes or dressing and covered with gravy. Available as a half order or whole order. Add the Salad bar for an additional cost.
Noodles Over Mashed Potatoes
An Amish Favorite! Choose beef noodles or chicken noodles. Available as a half order or whole order. Add the Salad bar for an additional cost.
Lite Side
Chicken, peppers, broccoli, mushrooms and onions stir fried and laid on a bed of white rice.
Baked Fish
8 oz. fish fillet with choice of 2 sides.
Breaded Mushrooms
Salad Bar
Salad Bar can be added to any sandwich or dinner for an additional cost.