Welcome to Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen
Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen, located in Middlefield, Ohio, is a charming eatery that embodies authentic home cooking with an Amish twist. Known for its hearty, comfort food, the restaurant features a tempting buffet filled with local, house-made delights, including melt-in-your-mouth Amish mashed potatoes, savory roast beef, and delectable pies crafted by Ms. Mary Yoder herself. The warm, welcoming atmosphere invites guests to savor each bite while experiencing exceptional service. Diners rave about dishes like broasted chicken and creamy gravies, making every visit a nostalgic culinary journey. Coupled with a gift shop offering homemade goods, this gem is a must-visit for comfort food lovers.
-
14743 North State Street, Middlefield, OH 44062, United States Hotline: +1 440-632-1939
Welcome to Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen, a charming slice of Amish tradition nestled in the heart of Middlefield, Ohio. Known for its comforting array of American-style home cooking, this beloved establishment emphasizes wholesome, homemade dishes that evoke the warmth of family gatherings. With its location at 14743 North State Street, Mary Yoder's invites diners to indulge in a buffet brimming with delicious options or select from a thoughtfully curated menu of classics.
The allure of Mary Yoder's lies not only in its meals but also in the experience. Customers rave about the gravy, praising it as "simply delicious and made to perfection." The broasted chicken is another standout, delivering that crispy exterior while remaining juicy on the inside. Whether you're savoring the Amish mashed potatoes, often described as the best they’ve had, or delighting in the homemade bread that accompanies every meal, you’ll find that each bite brims with authenticity.
What truly sets Mary Yoder's apart is its commitment to using local ingredients. Diners appreciate the flavor of dishes that are crafted with care and attention.Guest reviews highlight the restaurant's warm atmosphere, where the friendly staff treats you like family. Among the charming details are the complimentary rolls with apple butter and peanut butter, adding a homey touch that is hard to forget. And let's not overlook the desserts — the pies here are a must-try, with flavors that transport you back to simpler times. Gina from London remarks on the banana cream pie from Ms. Mary Yoder herself as the best she’s ever had.
For those who appreciate dining with a sense of community, Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen also features a gift shop displaying local baked goods and handicrafts, making it a holistic experience for both the palate and the soul. Whether you choose to load your plate at the buffet or opt for a satisfying meal from the menu, one thing is certain: a visit to Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen promises not just a meal, but a delightful journey into the heart of comfort food culture. So come hungry and leave with both a full belly and a happy heart!
I typically partake in the amazing buffet they have here; but today, I wanted something different. Although the pictures could be better, everything was delicious! Definitely worth many trips back, I have never had a meal here that wasn’t amazing and the staff is gracious and efficient.
This is home cooking comfort foods American style. If you are a lover or gravies, mashed potatoes & fried chicken this is a place for you. The gravies are just simply delicious & made to perfection. The broasted chicken is just as you would want it. You’ll be sure to go back for another plateful. They have a small but nice selection for a green salad & a half dozen choices for pasta salads, potato salad & other delicious side salads. Rolls come with the buffet & be sure to ask if they aren’t served up...because they are yummy too. Stuffing was exceptional & I was so loving what I had on my plate unfortunately I didn’t try anything else. We loved our meals & though this buffet is a little smaller than we are used to seeing, it did not disappoint as the quality was excellent. ***Make sure to get that gravy!
Mary Yoder's Amish Kitchen is a great place for great food. I went with my car club and despite the large group the service was great. I chose the dinner buffet as every option looked good and I wanted to try some things. The manager came over to check on us and someone mentioned steak. They offer steak on the last Saturday evening of the month and it is becoming popular. Each table was presented a plate of sliced steak so that everyone got a sample. The steak was delicious and many said that they would come back just for the steak. The basket of rolls was nice. The apple butter and peanut butter provided was a nice touch. I finally got to the buffet. The Amish mashed potatoes were the best I ever had. You must try. I tried the stuffing, Amish roast beef, noodles with chicken, roasted turkey, Amish meatloaf. The food is all local and house made. The dessert was great according to the others. I had no room left for dessert. They sell pies. I will leave that for my next visit. If you are in the area I highly recommend.
A large restaurant with a gift shop attached. Home cooked meals and desserts. The butterscotch pie was delicious. We also tried the chicken and biscuit special of the day. It was good and filling
The food was really good, except the sugar-free vanilla cheesecake. The cheesecake was very dry, and crumbly and had very little flavor. Our waitress was very friendly and helpful and checked on us often. The atmosphere was busy but not overly loud.
This restaurant offers basic country recipes that can be ordered off the menu or one can choose the buffet. The restaurant offers a country store with local baked goods, jellies, and fine decor. The store also offers a collection of country type items made in different countries. There is plenty of parking and a large room for meetings. We even got to see some horse and buggies and a large Amish farm on the way.
Best meatloaf I've ever had. Friendly, homely atmosphere with staff that really care about their customers. Great store with souvenirs and homemade Amish food. Clean bathrooms. Spacious parking. It was worth the trip. Greetings from London!
Ms. Mary Yoder made us this banana creme pie herself, what an amazing woman and an amazing establishment! Dining at this quaint Amish kitchen was an absolute delight from start to finish. The atmosphere was warm, welcoming, and felt like stepping back in time — simple yet beautifully cozy. Every dish was clearly made from scratch with fresh, local ingredients, and you could taste the love and tradition in every bite. The homemade bread, tender roast, and rich, buttery mashed potatoes were standouts, but honestly, everything on the table was outstanding. And don’t even get me started on the pies — truly the best I’ve ever had. The staff was kind, attentive, and made you feel like family. If you’re looking for authentic, hearty comfort food served with genuine hospitality, this little gem is a must-visit. I can’t wait to come back!